Introduction

Knowing how a person engages with music - having an awareness of their abilities, propensities and preferences - is essential in order to be able to offer them the most appropriate music provision, whether educational, therapeutic or recreational. This information can be gathered through formative assessment, using the descriptions set out in the Sounds of Intent framework. The framework can also be used for summative assessment, to celebrate an individual’s musical achievements at a given point in time, and to compare levels of musical engagement within and between cohorts to inform the planning and provision of music services more widely.

Formative Assessment

Formative assessment is best undertaken by adopting a ‘can do’ approach. Starting with Level 2 of the circular framework, work outwards, ticking off the headlines of musical engagement in each domain that, through observation, you are confident lie with an individual’s range of accomplishment. There will almost certainly come a point at which you are unsure, or where you feel a person partly meets a criterion, or who meets it some of the time. It may well be helpful, at this stage, to consult the full matrix of elements Elements Matrix DOC 1 in order to make a secure judgement. Each element in the matrix has associated strategies that can be used to plan musical activities that will be at an appropriate level for the person concerned.

Summative Assessment

The two methods of summative assessment asscoiated with the Sounds of Intent framework that are most commonly used are the ‘E•A•X’ (’emerging, achieving, excelling’) scheme and the system available on the ‘Classic’ Sounds of Intent website - www.soundsofintent.org.

The E•A•X Scheme

The E•A•X (’emerging, achieving, excelling’) scheme was first used by Lamorna Jewell-Gore, head of music at Linden Lodge School in London, and colleagues, who monitored the levels of musical engagement of a group of 20 young people with profound and multiple learning difficulties over a period of six months as they participated in a targeted programme of class music activities. [Link A:70 on database] Here, three sub-levels were identified, reactively, proactively and interactively, in relation to each of the six main Sounds of Intent levels - yielding a total of 18 indicators in each domain. These reference points consolidated the varying forms of engagement set out in the 24 individual ‘elements’. Elements Matrix DOC 1 They were further developed and refined in a pilot accreditation scheme run by Trinity College London in 2018 in partnership with Sounds of Intent Charity. Music teachers from across the UK entered 112 pupils at Sounds of Intent Levels 2, 3 and 4, by uploading videos of them in action to a secure site, and grading their engagement as ‘emerging, achieving, excelling’ in the proactive and interactive domains at one of these levels. The results were moderated by an expert panel. A high level of agreement was found between teachers and moderators; weighted Kappa = 0.83 in relation to levels as a whole, and weighted Kappa = 0.80 pertaining to sub-levels.

Introduction DOC 63

Analysis of the results, and feedback from the teachers and moderation panel indicated where the wording of the criteria and the definitions used could potentially be tightened up, and a revised version is set out in the Sounds of Intent Assessment Matrix (2021) to be found here. Assessment DOC 60 Note that assessment at Level 1 pertains to the musical environment and opportunities offered to someone who, as far as it is possible to ascertain, is unable to engage with music. Assessment at Levels 2-6 is of individuals‘ levels of musical engagement, alone or with others. There are two sheets for recording individual’s achievements, which can be used separately or, preferably, in combination. The table Assessment DOC 61 enables a more detailed account to be kept - data that can be used to populate a visual representation of the profile of a learner’s willingness and capacity to engage with music. Assessment DOC 62

The Classic Scheme

This enables attainment to be captured at any point and progress mapped over time, and is available as an online assessment tool at www.soundsofintent.org. It is based on an algorithm that takes into account both engagement and consistency as they pertain to any given element, both of which are evaluated on five-point scales. So, for example, in relation to element R.3.C (’recognises and responds to simple patterns formed through regular change’), the assessment criteria are as follows:

ScoreGauging engagement1Recognises and responds to onemanifestation of regular change in sound2Recognises and responds to twomanifestations of regular change in sound3Recognises and responds to threemanifestations of regular change in sound4Recognises and responds to fourmanifestations of regular change in sound5Recognises and responds to five or moremanifestations of regular change in soundScoreGauging consistency1Responses are observed rarely(on around one in eight occasions or fewer)2Responses are observed occasionally(on around one in four occasions)3Responses are observed regularly(on around one in two occasions)4Responses are observed frequently(on around three in four occasions)5Responses are observed consistently(on around seven in eight occasions or more)
PDF SVG
Figure 1

A score is calculated as the product of the two, giving a range of 1-25. As there are four elements in each of the three domains pertaining to every one of the six Sounds of Intent levels, this yields an entire scale of 4 x 3 x 6 x 25 = 1,800 potential increments of musical development. Contextual information can be particularly important in understanding how people with severe or profound learning difficulties are able to engage with sound and music, and the Classic Sounds of Intent website gives users the opportunity to log relevant observations to accompany the quantitative data. Many thousands of assessments have been undertaken using the online tool. Among its strengths are that it is particularly sensitive to the tiny changes in engagement that people with profound learning difficulties may show over considerable periods of time. Among the challenges that have been reported is that its very intricacy can be off-putting, given the limited time that practitioners often have to evaluate their pupils’, students’, clients’ or service-users‘ progress. A further issue is that, at the higher levels, there is no read-across to the other forms of music assessment that are currently in the public domain - particularly the graded music examination system in the UK, that is internationally recognised as a benchmark in instrumental and vocal achievement.

Emerging Achieving Excelling Sounds of Intent Assessment Matrix Main descriptor encounters sounds assessment of musicalopportunities offered assessment of individuals’ levels of musical engagement makes sounds unknowingly relates unwittingly through sound shows an awareness of sound intentionally makes or controls sound interacts with others using sound reacts to simple patterns in sound intentionally makes simple patterns in sound copies others’ sounds and/or isaware of own sounds being copied recognises musical motifs andthe relationships between them reproduces or creates musicalmotifs and potentially links them together engages in musical dialogues using motifs attends to whole pieces of music, anticipating prominentstructural features and responding to general characteristics performs, improvises and/or composes short and simple piecesof music, which may increase in complexity over time performs and/or improvises short and simple pieces of musicwith other people, which may increase in complexity over time has a mature, shared understanding and appreciation ofthe music of a particular culture, in a given style or styles performs and/or improvises solos of increasing sophisticationpersuasively within a given style and/or composes stylistically coherent pieces that are intended to convey particular effects performs and/or improvises pieces of music of increasingsophistication expressively with other people R, P, I Level 1 1 1 2 2 2 3 3 3 4 4 4 5 5 5 6 6 6 reactive proactive interactive reactive proactive interactive reactive proactive interactive reactive proactive interactive reactive proactive interactive reactive proactive interactive is systematically exposed to a wide range of sounds and music,but makes no discernible response the sounds made by life processes (such as breathing) are amplified and enhanced practitioners respond in sound to any sounds that are made unwittingly consistently reacts to one type of sound intentionally makes or causes one type of sound responds to one type of sound by making a sound ormakes one type of sound expecting a sound to be made in response consistently reacts to one type of simple pattern in sound intentionally makes one type of simple pattern in sound consistently recognises own individual sounds being copied orcopies another’s individual sounds consistently recognises one distinct musical motif sings or plays at least one motif that has a distinct musical identity,and which may be made up or copied from somewhere else any one of the following: (a) produces motifs that are meant to be repeated or varied by someone else;(b) repeats or varies motifs that are provided by someone else (as in ‘call and response’);(c) responds to motifs made by someone else with different motifs that follow coherently (as in ’question and answer’) six levels: performs or improvises pieces solo at the level of ‘Initial’ (pass, merit or distinction) or Grade 1 (pass, merit ordistinction) in the UK public music examination system, or composes pieces of equivalent length and complexity six levels: performs or improvises pieces as part of an ensemble at the level of ‘Initial’ (pass, meritand distinction) or Grade 1 (pass, merit and distinction) in the UK public music examination system has a mature understanding and appreciation of music in a given style,that is shared with other members of a particular culture three levels: performs or improvises pieces solo or composes at the level of Grade 6in the UK public music examination system (pass, merit and distinction) three levels: performs or improvises pieces as part of an ensemble at the level of Grade 6in the UK public music examination system (pass, merit and distinction) is systematically exposed to a wide range of sounds and music, in different environments,but makes no discernible response involuntary movements are used systematically to make or cause a range of different sounds practitioners make sounds in anticipation of ones that are made unwittingly consistently reacts to two types of sound intentionally makes or causes two different types of sound in two different ways responds to one type of sound by making a sound andmakes one type of sound expecting a sound to be made in response consistently reacts to two types of simple pattern in sound intentionally makes two different types of simple pattern in sound consistently recognises own individual sounds being copied andcopies another’s individual sounds consistently recognises two distinct musical motifs andrealises when one motif is repeated or varied (as in ‘call and response’) repeats or varies at least two motifs, orlinks different motifs together to form short musical narratives that need not be exactly in time or in tune any two of the following: (a) produces motifs that are meant to be repeated or varied by someone else;(b) repeats or varies motifs that are provided by someone else (as in ‘call and response’);(c) responds to motifs made by someone else with different motifs that follow coherently (as in ’question and answer’) six levels: performs or improvises pieces as part of an ensemble at the level of Grade 2 (pass, meritand distinction) or Grade 3 (pass, merit and distinction) in the UK public music examination system has a mature understanding and appreciation of music in two given styles or more,that is shared with other members of a particular culture orshows discernment in relation to different performers and performances three levels: performs or improvises pieces solo or composes at the level of Grade 7in the UK public music examination system (pass, merit and distinction) three levels: performs or improvises pieces as part of an ensemble at the level of Grade 7in the UK public music examination system (pass, merit and distinction) is systematically exposed to a wide range of sounds and music, in different environments,and linked to other sensory input, but makes no discernible response co-active movements are used systematically to make or cause a range of different sounds practitioners respond in sound to any sounds that are made unwittingly andmake sounds in anticipation of ones that are made unwittingly consistently reacts to at least three types of sound intentionally makes or causes three or more different types of sound in three or more different ways responds to two or more types of sound by making sounds andmakes two or more types of sound expecting sounds to be made in response consistently reacts to at least three types of simple pattern in sound intentionally makes at least three different types of simple pattern in sound consistently recognises own simple pattern or patterns in sound being copied andcopies another’s simple pattern or patterns in sound consistently recognises at least two distinct musical motifs andrealises when one motif is repeated or varied (as in ‘call and response’) andrealises when one motif is logically related to another that is different (as in ‘question and answer’) repeats and varies three or more motifs, andlinks different motifs together to form short musical narratives that need not be exactly in time or in tune six levels: performs or improvises pieces solo at the level of Grade 4 (pass, merit or distinction) or Grade 5 (pass, merit ordistinction) in the UK public music examination system, or composes pieces of equivalent length and complexity six levels: performs or improvises pieces as part of an ensemble at the level of Grade 4 (pass, meritand distinction) or Grade 5 (pass, merit and distinction) in the UK public music examination system has a mature understanding and appreciation of music in two given styles or more,that is shared with other members of a particular culture andshows discernment in relation to different performers and performances three levels: performs or improvises pieces solo or composes at the level of Grade 8in the UK public music examination system (pass, merit and distinction) or higher three levels: performs or improvises pieces as part of an ensemble at the level of Grade 8in the UK public music examination system (pass, merit and distinction) or higher six levels: performs or improvises pieces solo at the level of Grade 2 (pass, merit or distinction) or Grade 3 (pass, merit ordistinction) in the UK public music examination system, or composes pieces of equivalent length and complexity all three of the following: (a) produces motifs that are meant to be repeated or varied by someone else;(b) repeats or varies motifs that are provided by someone else (as in ‘call and response’);(c) responds to motifs made by someone else with different motifs that follow coherently (as in ’question and answer’) any one of the following: (a) anticipates prominent structural features of short pieces (played and not sung);(b) recognises or responds to at least two different metres or grooves (such as three and four time, rap or rock), shown,for example, through moving to the music in different ways; (c) recognises or responds in different ways to differentmodes (such as major and minor keys) any two of the following: (a) anticipates prominent structural features of short pieces (played and not sung);(b) recognises or responds to at least two different metres or grooves (such as three and four time, rap or rock), shown,for example, through moving to the music in different ways; (c) recognises or responds in different ways to different modes(such as major and minor keys) all three of the following: (a) anticipates prominent structural features of short pieces (played and not sung);(b) recognises or responds to at least two different metres or grooves (such as three and four time, rap or rock), shown,for example, through moving to the music in different ways; (c) recognises or responds in different ways to different modes(such as major and minor keys) R.1 P.1 I.1 R.2 P.2 I.2 R.3 P.3 I.3 R.4 P.4 I.4 R.5 P.5 I.5 R.6 P.6 I.6 R.1.Emerging P.1.Emerging I.1.Emerging R.2.Emerging P.2.Emerging I.2.Emerging R.3.Emerging P.3.Emerging I.3.Emerging R.4.Emerging P.4.Emerging I.4.Emerging R.5.Emerging P.5.Emerging I.5.Emerging R.6.Emerging P.6.Emerging I.6.Emerging R.1.Achieving P.1.Achieving I.1.Achieving R.2.Achieving P.2.Achieving I.2.Achieving R.3.Achieving P.3.Achieving I.3.Achieving R.4.Achieving P.4.Achieving I.4.Achieving R.5.Achieving P.5.Achieving I.5.Achieving R.6.Achieving P.6.Achieving I.6.Achieving R.1.Excelling P.1.Excelling I.1.Excelling R.2.Excelling P.2.Excelling I.2.Excelling R.3.Excelling P.3.Excelling I.3.Excelling R.4.Excelling P.4.Excelling I.4.Excelling R.5.Excelling P.5.Excelling I.5.Excelling R.6.Excelling P.6.Excelling I.6.Excelling
PDF SVG
Figure 2

Sounds of Intent Record of Musical Achievement Date Name Sheet No.R•P•ILevelE•A•XContextObservationInterpretationAssessor
PDF SVG
Figure 3

Assessment
PDF PNG
Figure 4